The Person Who Arguably Invented “The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants” Didn’t Write It. That’s the First Thing You Should Know About Jodi Lynn Anderson.
Before her first novel. Before Tiger Lily landed on TIME’s list of the best YA books ever written. Before the MFA, the move to Costa Rica, the move to Dakar, the endless stray pets. There was a conversation at 17th Street Productions in New York between two editors, where Jodi Anderson told a story about sharing a pair of pants with her girlfriends one summer. Her colleague Ann Brashares turned that story into one of the most commercially successful YA series of the 2000s.
Depending on which version you believe, Anderson either graciously sparked an idea that became Brashares’ book — or she created the original proposal and watched another author get chosen to write it.
Neither version appears in any author bio or interview with Anderson that I’ve ever found. She doesn’t talk about it. Ann Brashares does, occasionally, warmly.
That tells you something about who Jodi Lynn Anderson is. And it’s more interesting than you might expect.
Quick Bio
| Detail | Info |
| Born/hometown | Grew up in a lake town in northern New Jersey |
| Education | BA, British Literature, University of Maryland; MFA, Bennington College |
| Early career | Editor at HarperCollins; then 17th Street Productions/Publications, NY |
| The Sisterhood question | Anderson told Ann Brashares the pants-sharing story; HarperCollins UK credits her as “creator of the proposal” |
| Debut novel | Peaches (2005, HarperCollins) |
| Most celebrated book | Tiger Lily (2012) — TIME’s 100 Best YA Books of All Time |
| Major awards | ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults (Tiger Lily, 2013); multiple starred reviews |
| MFA completed | Approximately 2014 (from Bennington College) |
| Current home | Dakar, Senegal (husband works for USAID/US Embassy) |
| Family | Married, one son, “endless parade of stray pets” |
| Website | jodilynnanderson.com |
| Notable criticism | Debbie Reese (AICL) critique of Tiger Lily‘s indigenous characterization (2012) |
A Lake Town in New Jersey and a Notebook Full of Secrets
She has described herself as a secretive, shy kid who poured thoughts into notebooks and read constantly. That portrait — the introverted child sitting in the woods near a New Jersey lake watching clouds — is consistent across everything she’s said publicly. Which isn’t much.
She studied British Literature at the University of Maryland. Not creative writing. Not education. British Lit — which is its own kind of clue about what mattered to her as a reader. She wanted to understand the tradition before she added to it.
She went to New York after college. Got a job as an editor at HarperCollins. Moved to 17th Street Productions/Publications, a book packaging company that specialized in YA and middle grade. And here’s where the Sisterhood thing becomes unavoidable.
HarperCollins’ UK website described Anderson as “the creator of the proposal for The Sisterhood of the Travelling Pants.” Ann Brashares — who wrote the book and built a career on the series — has said in her own words that Anderson “talked about a summer where she and her [friends shared pants], and that immediately sparked a bunch of ideas.” The SparkNotes biography of Brashares presents two versions of what happened next: in one, Anderson told the anecdote and Brashares developed it freely; in the other, Anderson created the proposal and believed she would be the one writing the book.
Nobody has accused anyone of anything. There’s no lawsuit, no public bitterness on record. Brashares has blurbed Anderson’s own books with genuine warmth — “packed with loveliness” is a real pull quote on Peaches. The two women have, by every available indication, remained friends.
But the ambiguity sits there. An idea that became a mega-franchise. Two women who were both at the table. One who wrote the book. One who, within a few years, became a novelist on her own terms.
Leaving New York for Peaches
She moved to Atlanta. Fell in love with Georgia peaches, peach pie, peach ice cream. Then she moved to Costa Rica, which took her far from all of it.
That homesickness — specific, sensory, rooted in Georgia food she could no longer find — became Peaches (2005), her debut novel. Then The Secrets of Peaches (2006). Then Love and Peaches (2008). Three novels about friendship set on a Georgia peach orchard, narrated across a whole summer the way summer should be narrated: slowly, fully, with heat.
She was writing these while working at 17th Street and then after, from wherever she was living. The displacement feeds the work. That’s something you notice reading her bibliography from start to finish — she writes about leaving, about distance, about girls trying to figure out who they’ll become in places that feel temporary. That’s not an accident for someone whose adult life has been a series of relocations: New York, Atlanta, Costa Rica, Washington D.C., Asheville, Dakar.
The May Bird trilogy came alongside the Peaches books — a middle grade fantasy series about a girl who can see ghosts, starting with May Bird and the Ever After (2005). Three very different registers: contemporary YA realism, middle grade fantasy, both running simultaneously. She was not, even at the start, a single-lane writer.
2012: The Quiet Revolution of Tiger Lily
Tiger Lily is the book that changed Anderson’s career. But let’s be precise about what it actually did — and what it didn’t.
The premise: before Wendy arrived in Neverland, there was Tiger Lily, and there was Peter Pan, and there was something between them. The narrator is Tinkerbell — specifically a Tinkerbell who cannot be seen or heard by the humans she observes, only by us. This was the structural genius of the book. Tinkerbell is a witness who cannot intervene, which means the reader knows things characters don’t, and the whole love story is drenched in impending loss before it even starts.
Tiger Lily earned four starred reviews. It made TIME’s 100 Best YA Books of All Time. ALA gave it Best Fiction for Young Adults in 2013. Publishers Weekly called it “expressive, graceful language” and “captivating.” It is, by almost every critical measure, a successful and affecting book.
And.
Debbie Reese — scholar, educator, tribally enrolled at Nambé Pueblo, founder of American Indians in Children’s Literature — reviewed it in 2012 and found it troubling. Her specific critique: the character names that Anderson gave to Tiger Lily’s people (Pine Sap, Moon Eye, Tik Tok, Bat Wing, Aunt Sticky Feet) are the kind of cutesy, nature-adjacent names that have historically been used to mark indigenous fictional characters as “other” — simple, nature-bound, not fully realized humans in the same register as European characters. She’d seen it before in other books. She didn’t find Anderson’s version of Tiger Lily to have escaped the problem.
This is a real criticism that received real engagement in the YA criticism community in 2012. It’s also largely absent from any mainstream profile of Anderson or retrospective on Tiger Lily. The book sits on TIME’s list. The critique sits in the archive of Newspaper Rock, a blog dedicated to indigenous representation in media. These two facts coexist without anyone in mainstream media finding it particularly worth synthesizing.
I’m not settling the question here. I’m noting that the conversation happened, that it was substantive, and that the praise-without-context version of Anderson’s best book is missing something real.
The MFA, the Voice, and the Books That Followed
Anderson completed her MFA at Bennington College around 2014. She said afterward that the experience “taught me to trust my voice.” That’s an interesting thing to say after ten years of professional publishing — but the books after 2014 do feel different in scope and ambition.
My Diary from the Edge of the World (2015): a middle grade novel written as a journal, with a narrator processing grief and the end of the world simultaneously. Midnight at the Electric (2017): three timelines, three women, the Dust Bowl, World War One, and a climate-changed near future, all connected by a house in Kansas. Multiple starred reviews. Barnes & Noble Best of Year. Atlantic Best of Year. It’s the kind of structural and emotional ambition that wins the reader trust rather than demanding it.
Then the Thirteen Witches series started with The Memory Thief (2021), then Each Night Was Illuminated (2023), written from Dakar, Senegal, where she now lives because her husband works for USAID at the US Embassy.
The biography on her most recent book says she lives in Senegal with her husband and their children — note the plural, which is different from earlier bios that said “son” and “endless parade of stray pets.” Either the children are inclusive of strays (very possible) or things have changed. This matters less than the consistent fact of her life: wherever she is, she writes books about women and girls navigating loss, climate, grief, time, and the thing underneath all of it that she never quite names directly but that you feel on every page.
What the Mainstream Coverage Gets Wrong
Here’s the article you usually get about Jodi Lynn Anderson: a brief mention of Tiger Lily on some list, a publisher bio from whatever book she’s currently promoting, a birth date that’s sometimes wrong (1953 appears in at least one database, which would make Peaches her debut at age 52 — an error). Nobody writes the full arc. Nobody mentions the Sisterhood question seriously. Nobody engages with the Reese critique alongside the TIME recognition.
The version of Anderson that exists in the public record is a partial sketch: quiet, New Jersey, woods, notebooks, British Lit degree, YA books, lives somewhere. The actual texture of her career — the editing years, the intellectual genealogy, the structural risks she takes in books like Midnight at the Electric, the persistent critical blind spot around Tiger Lily — none of that makes it into the casual profile.
She’s been writing for twenty years. She has a readership that follows her across entirely different genres and registers. She completed a graduate degree in her thirties or forties and said it changed how she trusted herself. She moves countries when her husband’s work takes him there and she writes anyway.
You don’t write about a person like this as if she’s a footnote in the story of someone else’s pants.
Final Words
Jodi Lynn Anderson is the kind of writer who rewards attention. Not because her books are difficult — most of them are genuinely accessible, written for middle grade and YA audiences with clarity and warmth. But because the arc of her career, the structural choices in her best work, and the tensions that exist around her most celebrated novel all become more interesting the more closely you look.
She started in the industry. She learned how books are made from the inside, which is both an advantage and a complication when you become the person making them. She wrote a book that TIME thinks is among the best hundred in her genre — and that book has a real representation problem that the mainstream critical conversation mostly elided. Both things are true.
She lives now in Dakar, which is not where any of her books are set, because her husband’s work takes him there. She keeps writing. She keeps adding stray pets to whatever home they’re inhabiting. She probably still has notebooks.
The girl in the New Jersey woods is still writing in them.
FAQs
1. Who is Jodi Lynn Anderson?
An American author of young adult and middle grade fiction, born in New Jersey. She started as an editor at HarperCollins and 17th Street Productions before publishing her debut novel Peaches in 2005. She is best known for Tiger Lily (2012), which appeared on TIME’s 100 Best YA Books of All Time, and is also the author of the Peaches and May Bird trilogies, Midnight at the Electric, and the Thirteen Witches series.
2. Did Jodi Lynn Anderson create The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants?
She sparked it. Ann Brashares has credited a conversation with Anderson — in which Anderson described sharing pants with friends one summer — as the origin of the idea. HarperCollins UK went further, calling Anderson “the creator of the proposal.” What happened next is described differently depending on the source: either Anderson told the story and Brashares ran with it freely, or Anderson created the actual proposal and Brashares was chosen as the writer. Anderson has not publicly addressed the full story.
3. What is Tiger Lily about?
It’s a retelling of the Peter Pan story told from Tiger Lily’s perspective, narrated by a Tinkerbell who can observe but not be seen or heard. It focuses on the romance between Tiger Lily and Peter Pan that existed before Wendy arrived in Neverland. It earned four starred reviews, made TIME’s 100 Best YA Books of All Time list, and won ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults in 2013.
4. Was Tiger Lily criticized for its indigenous representation?
Yes. Debbie Reese, scholar and founder of American Indians in Children’s Literature (tribally enrolled at Nambé Pueblo), published a critique in 2012 noting that the character names given to Tiger Lily’s people relied on the same patronizing, nature-adjacent naming conventions used to “other” indigenous characters in children’s literature. This critique received engagement in the YA critical community but is largely absent from mainstream coverage of the book.
5. Where does Jodi Lynn Anderson live now?
As of her most recent book (2022–2023), she lives in Dakar, Senegal, with her husband, who works for USAID at the US Embassy. She has previously lived in New Jersey, New York, Atlanta, Costa Rica, Washington D.C., and Asheville, North Carolina.
6. What is Jodi Lynn Anderson’s education?
She holds a BA in British Literature from the University of Maryland and an MFA in Writing and Literature from Bennington College, which she completed approximately around 2014.
7. What are Jodi Lynn Anderson’s best books for adults?
She writes specifically for younger readers, but Midnight at the Electric (2017) and Tiger Lily (2012) both have substantial adult readerships. Midnight at the Electric spans three timelines including a near-future climate-changed America, WWI England, and the Dust Bowl, and earned multiple starred reviews.
8. What is the Thirteen Witches series?
A middle grade fantasy series beginning with The Memory Thief (2021) and continuing with The Palace of Dreams (2022). It follows a girl named Rosie who can see thirteen powerful witches, one of whom — the Memory Thief — has cursed her mother.
9. Has Jodi Lynn Anderson written any adult fiction?
No. Her work is specifically categorized as YA and middle grade, though she has said her books are written for people of all ages who remember what it felt like to be young.
10. Why does Jodi Lynn Anderson move around so much?
Her husband’s work — USAID, which places him at US embassies internationally — has taken them to multiple countries. She has described relocating to Dakar in a Horn Book interview, treating it as simply the current chapter of a mobile life.
11. What should I read first if I want to try Jodi Lynn Anderson?
Tiger Lily if you want literary YA that reimagines a classic. Midnight at the Electric if you want ambitious multi-timeline emotional fiction. Peaches if you want warm contemporary YA about female friendship. The Memory Thief if you’re reading with a younger reader, approximately 9–12.
Beyond the headlines, discover what’s worth knowing — TheTrendist.
One Comment